If someone wants to make his wife dance in public and make money off that. I mostly have no business in that. But when the dancing goes on the internet and makes an active effort to support
vedanindaka like Mahadevi Mata in her efforts to stop the WMM book. I have to make it my business.
https://www.facebook.com/mahadevi.dasi.5 then I have to explain to people what is the character of the dancing girl and or the value of her opinions.
1. "The classical singing and dancing is still very very respectful in India" Indeed so. it must be encouraged. preserved and cultivated .BUT in the right arena or in the right environment.
2. "Dancing and singing in front of public is not only meant for prostitute. "- "public" this word should mean female audience.
3. preksanam- to look at. So, to look a woman's body by a man is forbidden. How is a man to even watch a woman dancing?
smaranam kirtanam kelih
preksanam guhyabhasanam
sankalpo `dhyavasayas ca
kriya-nirvrttir eva ca
4. So this is fundamentally flawed. The option left for a man is to go to a mata-dancing concert and close his eyes. That is absurd. So why go in the first place?
5. "still they are getting full respect" respect from persons who are unaware of the scriptural jurisdictions of illicit sex.
6. "Classical singing and dancing is not a Bollywood singing and dancing" yes, it is a milder form of sex life. It may not be grotesque and fully erotic to blast the senses but it is illicit none the less. Something like doing illicit activity with a saree wearing, tilak wearing prostitute and putting on Bhimsen Joshi's raga bhairavi in the back ground. Sounds very vedic, very cultural but the core activity is illicit sex.
7. "Indian classical singing and dancing comes from Vedas especially Sam Veda." The entire basis of Sankara's demoniac mayavad is the veda especially the highest part of the veda i.e. the vedanta sutra. Thus, vedic singing and dancing should not be miss applied.
8. All women singing and dancing should be limited to mahila satsangs e.g. the ones we indians have in or before marriage ceremonies.
9. "this art only from Guru Sissya parampara" all vedic arts are only learnt from guru-sisya parampara e.g. black magic, ghost worship, human sacrifice, communication with the dead, so on and so forth. Just because there was a guru involved it is not at all bonafide. E.g. mayavad is also learnt from the guru sisya parampara of adi-sankara
10. "How can you say this is meant for prostitute" it is meant for Krishna's pleasure but it is used by iskcon-feminist supporters like Mrs. Vrinda Setha et al for their non vedic desires.
Manikar Das Brahmachari added 2 new photos — with Ananda Krsna Das and 16 others.
We must avoid making our mothers dance in public in front of male audiences. This is unchaste.
Women traditionally dance in mahila satsangs where men are not allowed entry. This is chaste.
Thus, in a 'women only' get-together our mothers are given the sheltered freedom to sing and dance for Krishna without having to worry about men.
We must further educate our daughters to refrain from supporting the ban on the book Women: Mothers or Masters.
...See More
No comments :
Post a Comment